Tag Archives: online advertising

The Force isn’t strong

I sometimes wonder what people who don’t work in the marketing and advertising talk about with their colleagues when they get in to work in the mornings. Yesterday everyone at work was talking about the new Star Wars / adidas commerical that had aired over the weekend with real excitement – maybe the rest of the population just isn’t so easily impressed?

For those who haven’t had the pleasure they can check it out here:

So what’s the verdict? Of course it’s cool… did you not see Snoop with a lightsaber? But for me, that is it. It’s like some ad executives sat around the boardroom saying, “wouldn’t it be cool if we could recreate the scene from Star Wars with David Beckham?”. And then they made it…

Maybe you can be cool by association but this ad doesn’t really have a message apart from a vague connection to the World Cup, based on the sign at the beginning. This is nowhere near as good as Nike’s “Write the Future”. But then again, I don’t have “Like” it to see it…

No point advertising on Facebook?

Firstly, congratulations to Facebook on reaching 350 million users worldwide.  That’s pretty impressive since they are only 5 years old.

The reason I mention this is that I read an article in the Observer by John Naughton suggesting that despite this huge audience, it “cannot be tapped”.  He goes on to argue that paid search is the only form of online advertising that works. He rounds off his article with the following statement:

“The inescapable conclusion is that anyone who thinks advertising is the key to sustainable online businesses in any field other than search should think again.”

I can’t help but feel that this piece was written by someone who doesn’t have a great deal of knowledge on the subject of making Facebook work for advertisers, or the online ad industry in general. Firstly, I know from first hand experience that advertising on Facebook can, and does work for Facebook. For one of my clients we are generating more activity than all of their other online channels (paid search included!) put together. I don’t want to dwell on the subject but you can read more here.

The other point he makes is that only paid search works and advertising in any other channel in unsustainable. Frankly, there are a lot of people working in the digital industry across a wide rang of channels and disciplines that would beg to differ.  Of course, search is always going to deliver a high return on investment but display, affiliates and social media all have a part to play in driving incremental sales online. He also fails to account for the impact of branding online and the impact this has on consumer choice. There a so many fantastic creative agencies out there producing great work – so does the fact that less than 1% of people click through on that creative mean we should all give up and go home?

I would expect more from a piece in the Observer.

Can’t Touch this

I’ve really got to stop punning on these blog titles. Anyway I wanted to share what I think is a fantastic use of digital advertising for Apple’s iPod Touch. You can read more and see a video of the placement here.

The ad ups the ante on Nintendo’s Wario Land: Shake It ad which appeared earlier this year on YouTube. These sort of bespoke placements rely on publisher support (in this case Yahoo!) and in my opinion takes online ads to a new, exciting level. Hopefully we’ll see more like this in 2009.

Hope you like it too.